RSS
email
1

WILL INDIAN "OBAMA" RISE FOR THE CHANGE ?

In the week when 46-year-old Barack Obama was being anointed the Democratic party's presidential candidate in the United States, Tamil Nadu's chief minister M Karunanidhi was being felicitated on his 85th birthday. While Obama made a stirring speech in front of hundreds of cheering young Americans, the DMK patriarch mumbled a few words on stage in the company of his two sons, MK Stalin and Azhagiri, both jostling to be heir-apparents to their ageing father's legacy. The contrast could not have been more stark: in America, Obama represents "change" and "equal opportunity", a charismatic Afro-American Harvard-educated lawyer who has risen up the political ladder through merit and hard work.

In India, Karunanidhi and sons are symbols of a static order, where a political party is a family business and where the top posts are closed for talented outsiders. Obama is the man from nowhere, throwing open the doors of the Washington establishment, renewing stale old political processes, with a completely new energy.

Can the Indian political system throw up a Barack Obama-like figure who exemplifies in his own person, the "change we can believe in" tagline? Unlikely. Leave aside the two cadre-based parties -- the left and the BJP - and every political formation in this country is an extension of a presiding family with strict rules of entry and upward mobility. In tightly-knit regional parties, this phenomenon gets accentuated.

Parties like Lalu Yadav's Rashtriya Janata Dal, for example, don't even have elections for office-bearers, the decision on who to appoint are the sole prerogative of an individual. A Sharad Pawar's NCP may claim to be encouraging "young" talent, but can the Baramati boss say with any conviction that his successor will be someone other than his nephew or daughter? The National Conference in Kashmir, the Akalis in Punjab, the Biju Janata Dal in Orissa, the TDP in Andhra Pradesh, the Samajwadi party, the Shiv Sena: a majority of political parties in this country are dynastic in structure, run like feudal oligarchies.

Could the Congress party throw up a leader outside the Nehru-Gandhi family? Very doubtful given the manner in which the party organization is now completely subservient to the notion of the First Family. That a section of the Congress chooses to push for Priyanka Gandhi, even though she has made it amply clear that she doesn't want to join politics, is proof of how the party is unable to look beyond a family for leadership.Even the BJP, which can legitimately claim to have stayed away from actively encouraging dynastical politics, is hardly a meritocratic organization.

The recent elections in Karnataka provided a glaring example of how party tickets in several constituencies were distributed on the basis of money power alone, and not on ideological commitment or organizational ability. That in over four decades, the BJP has thrown up just two "national" leaders - Vajpayee and Advani, both now octogenarians - is evidence of a rigidly controlled party structure that is unwilling to open itself up to change. It is a bit like the Hindu joint family syndrome: the fear of allowing a "younger", more dynamic leadership is seen to be against a tradition that places a premium on age and experience.

A geriatric leadership has been the burden of the left as well. At 64, a Prakash Karat may be a representative of the next generation of left leadership, but his ascent is also the culmination of more than 40 years within the party apparatus and he cannot be seen as someone who has carved a dramatically different path for the left or has infused it with original, distinctive ideas.

Indeed, in structural terms, Indian politics it seems has lesser and lesser space for fresh, independent minds: individuals who will question the prevailing orthodoxy, who will challenge entrenched mindsets, and who will build new constituencies. Instead, the focus remains on those who are either part of the "family" system or are rewarded for flattery and for practising status quoist politics.

India's generation next politicians may dress and talk smart, but how many of them can claim to be truly empowered? Satisfied with the crumbs of an insignificant ministry or political post, a majority seem to have little option but to wait their turn. After all, they are in politics because they are dutiful sons; not because they have the passion to change their fathers' values.

Contrast the passion and excitement that Obama has ignited within the younger Americans with the cynicism and apathy that our netas seem to generate. A Rahul Gandhi, for example, may have chosen a 20-20 cricket tournament to encourage youth in Amethi, but can that ever be a substitute for a concrete programme of action for the young to enter public life? When is the last time any Indian politician for that matter made a serious effort at reaching out to young India, or redefining the rules of political power?

In the end, the Obama phenomenon is not just about him being the first African-American to have won a major party nomination for the US presidency. Race may have been a contributing factor in highlighting the change agenda, but there was surely more to his success than just contrasting his roots with the political pedigree of his rival. Obama won because he was able to symbolize a generational change, an America fatigued by the Washington consensus and itching to break away from the Clinton-Bush duopoly over power.

For the moment, India awaits her Barack Obama.

Read more
0

IF YOU ARE IN U.S. AND WANT YOUR CHILD TO BE PRESIDENT ? RULE # 1 .................BE A BAD DAD !!!

( In U.S.A. a new sensational book has been uncovered and is written by the famous best selling author Doug Wead. The name of the book is 'The raising of a President'. Doug Wead has remained as a personal adviser to the President Bush Sr. and has been closely associated with many others. In his book he reveals the facts that are far more astonishing and surprising. As he has worked with many Presidents closely, he got some of the facts tabled. )


Augustine Washington expected great things from his first-born son, and he gave him a fine education, sent him to Europe and set him up with an estate later called Mount Vernon.
Washington's son, of course, was the father the U.S.. But not that one - that was Lawrence Washington. By the time George came around, Pa Washington couldn't much be bothered; George got only a year of schooling, and wasn't even trained in the family iron works.
There's a Father's Day lesson in this, for any dad determined to launch a son into the Oval Office. Forget the pep talks and character-building homilies - paternal neglect or absence are a much better bet.
That's the verdict of presidential historian Doug Wead, the author of "The Raising of a President," a study of the parents of the country's 43 chief executives. As he researched the book, a distinct pattern emerged - strong, doting mothers and distant fathers.
"The most striking thing is the absence of the father," says Wead, a former aide to George H.W. Bush. "The presidents tend to be mama's boys. They're empowered by their mothers and rejected by the father that wasn't there, and they go off and do great things to win the approval of this distant figure who rejected them either through death or through absence. You just see it constantly."
Textbook cases include Andrew Jackson, whose father died before he was born (making him one of 19 presidents whose father died before they reached 30), Ulysses Grant, whose father offered him little other than contempt until he became president, and Franklin Delano Roosevelt, whose father "almost literally abandoned him - he basically said to his wife, this one's yours," says Wead.
Roosevelt is one of a statistically improbable number of presidents who bear their mother's name, notes Wead, including Lyndon Baines Johnson (Rebecca Baines), John Fitzgerald Kennedy (Rose Fitzgerald), Richard Millhouse Nixon (Hannah Millhouse), Woodrow Wilson (Janet Woodrow), and Ronald Wilson Reagan (Nelly Wilson).
In this sense, both Barack Obama and John McCain are classic presidential material. While their individual experiences were very different - Obama pined for a father who abandoned his family when Barack was two, while McCain's four-star-admiral father was a looming presence whom he hugely admired - the common thread is that neither was present.

"McCain certainly admired his father, but he was absent much of the time," says Stanley Renshon, a professor of political science at CUNY and a psychoanalyst, who's written books on both Clinton and George W. Bush, the latter titled "In His Father's Shadow."
"The requirement of being in the military is that you're often away, especially if there's a war. So there's a tension there."
For a parallel, look no further than George W. Bush, whose powerful, successful father has freely admitted that wife Barbara raised W. singlehandedly while he was off tending to business. Meanwhile, Obama finds a mirror in Bill Clinton, whose father died before he was born.
"With Clinton there was the search, the looking back to try to recover this mythical figure in some way, and it's absolutely crystal clear in Obama's case," says Renshon. "He literally spends his whole first book on the quest for who his father was."
Harold I. Gullan, the author "First Fathers: The Men Who Inspired Our Presidents," as well as a separate book on presidents' mothers, concurs with Wead that generally speaking, "Mothers are stronger influences." (He also notes that many presidents' were their mother's clear favorite - accounting for why "if you look at the siblings, they always have some idiot brother" a la Roger Clinton or Billy Carter).
Gullan, though, sees presidential fathers as having a more direct influence than the Freudian one Wead notes. The most notable common thread he sees is that they tend to be "restless, ambitious entrepreneurs," with "ambition for their son to do well."
Classic examples include Woodrow Wilson's father, who "put immense pressures on him," Joseph Kennedy, who was determined to make one of his sons the first Irish Catholic president (though his eldest, Joe, was the chosen one, until he died young), and both William Howard Taft and John Quincy Adams - whose excessive heft and gaunt frame, respectively, can be directly attributed to "the tremendous pressures put on them by their parents to excel," says Gullan.
Wead and Gullan agree that presidential dads tend to be accomplished in some way, even if they were failures in others - like Andrew Johnson's father, who was poor, but considered a great local hero for having saved a boatful of prominent citizens from drowning.
As for the worst presidential dad of all time, Gullan and Wead are in agreement: Thomas Lincoln, a "dull, ignorant man," who showered Abraham with verbal and physical abuse. Of course, if his father had lightened up, Lincoln might never have been instilled with the drive to become the country's greatest president. As Wead puts it, assembling his book, "I developed a real respect for Freud."
Read more